Angeloni’s
I ended the year at Angeloni’s in Caldwell, and it felt like the perfect cozy wrap to a full dining year. Their signature “Thinny Thin” pizzas are exactly as described—ultra-crispy, light, and flavorful. I loved how the crust had just the right snap without feeling brittle, letting the cheese, sauce, and toppings shine through. The menu isn’t just pizza, though—there …